Monday, June 24, 2019

The 761st Black Panthers, they came out fighting

It's an amazing ride through our history to look back at World War II and see that we fought with segregated units, and these units, black and white, fought with incredulous gallantry and courage, together, side by side, often so intermingled that the word "segregated" during battle had little meaning. Many of our leaders at the time openly argued that black-Americans could not fight in modern warfare. Of course, they were wrong. Many of us are well aware of the famous Tuskegee Airmen, but how many of you know about the 761st "Black Panther" Tank Battalion, part of Patton's vaunted 3rd Army that bolted from Normandy to Germany virtually overnight? There is a great deal of history tied up with the 761st, and a great deal of bravery far beyond the call of duty. The story of the 761st is a story about black-American valor. It is also an American story of service, sacrifice, tenacity and resolve. And, it is a story about an alliance that took down an evil German empire, piece by piece.

Just about everyone knows Kareem Abdul-Jabbar is among the greatest basketball players to ever hit the court, but perhaps fewer know he is also an accomplished author. He is known to have once said:

"I can do something else besides stuff a ball through a hoop. My biggest resource is my mind.” 

His most recent book, published by Broadway Books in May 2004, is Brothers in Arms, co-authored by Anthony Walton. This book is about the 761st Tank Battalion, an all-black military unit that distinguished itself in WWII in Europe as part of General Patton's 3rd Army. The 761st became known as the “Black Panthers.”

There is much to learn about this tank battalion, and all the history in which it was immersed. We've picked out a few things that peaked our interest.

The battalion was constituted on March 15, 1942 and was activated on April 1, 1942 at Camp Claiborne, Louisiana.  Building began in 1940, prior to the WWII for the US. The next photo shows it in 1941.

It was initially a tent camp, located about 17 miles southwest of Alexandria. Over one-half million soldiers were trained here.  


African-Americans, of course, have served in American military forces with distinction since the Revolutionary War.

Nonetheless, there was considerable reluctance to use them in armored (and air) units in WWII. Many senior officers felt African-Americans lacked the needed intelligence and moral qualities. The debate was heated and often racist. Secretary of War Stimson reflects the widely held attitude in this statement of September 27, 1940:

"Leadership is not embedded in the Negro race yet and to try to make commissioned officers to lead the men into battle — colored men — is to work disaster to both. Colored troops do very well under white officers but every time we try to lift them a little bit beyond where they can go, disaster and confusion follows. In the draft, we are preparing to give Negroes a fair shot in every service, however, even in aviation where I doubt if they will not produce disaster there. Nevertheless, they are going to have a try, but I hope to Heaven’s sake they won’t mix the white and the colored troops together in the same units for then we shall certainly have trouble." 

Stimson forgot that African-American officers served in the Union Army during the US Civil War.

However, men such as Major General J. Lesley McNair (later promoted to Lieutenant General), had for some time argued strongly to bring black Americans into army combat units, including tank units. He was realistic, and knew the manpower pool was not inexhaustible, so he concluded that blacks had to be used in combat units.

In addition, black organizations were pressuring the Roosevelt administration to allow black soldiers to serve on the same level as white soldiers. Eleanor Roosevelt is said to have joined this lobbying effort to put pressure on FDR as well.

Finally, in 1940 Congress passed the Selective Training and Service Act and on September 16, 1940, FDR signed it. This legislation required there be no discrimination on account of race in the selection and training of soldiers. While this law did go into effect, the segregation of units was maintained.

In 1942, General McNair became responsible for training, equipping and organizing all Army units except the Army Air Corps.

By the time the 761st got to France, in October 1944, Patton's 3rd Army was already on its way across France. General Patton, not originally fond of the idea of black armored units, welcomed the 761st with these remarks:

“Men, you're the first Negro tankers to ever fight in the American Army. I would never have asked for you if you weren't good. I have nothing but the best in my Army. I don't care what color you are as long as you go up there and kill those Kraut sons of bitches. Everyone has their eyes on you and is expecting great things from you. Most of all, your race is looking forward to you. Don't let them down and damn you, don't let me down!"

A decision was made to organize the 5th Tank Group as an all-black organization, though that is a bit of a misnomer, since white officers were assigned to it. Three black tank battalions were created to fill this 5th Tank Group.

The first was the 758th Tank Battalion (Light), which formed in March 1941 at Fort Knox, Kentucky.  This was the first tank battalion in American history organized with black soldiers. In 1949, the 758th Tank Battalion was redesignated the 64th Heavy Tank Battalion.

The 761st was the next to activate, and it was followed by the 784th, activated on April 1, 1943.

The 761st was given an armored patch with nothing embroidered into it. Many of the men went to their local Post Exchange (PX) and had the 761 embroidered into it. The patch shown here is courtesy of the First Sergeant Wilson, Sr. Memorial Album, presented by

Captain Ivan Harrison, with the help of a draftsman, drew up the unit crest and their motto, "Come out fighting."

And "Come out fighting" the 761st did. Of the three black tank battalions, the 761st was the first to go to war, landing on Omaha Beach at Normandy, France on October 10, 1944. The battalion was part of General Patton's 3rd US Army. It entered combat on November 7, 1944, participating in an assault on the French towns of Moyenvic and Vic-sur-Seille, helping the 26th Infantry Division breakout near the fortress city of Metz.

The 761st won its first victory right away, and continued winning. It crossed the German border on December 14, 1944. The 761st Tank Battalion participated in the American counteroffensive during and after the Battle of the Bulge, supporting the 17th Airborne Division. During the period December 31, 1944 and February 2, 1945, the "Black Panthers" were able to split the German lines at three points, thereby preventing the resupply of the enemy forces surrounding American troops at Bastogne. In the spring of 1945, the battalion crossed the Main River in support of the 103rd infantry Division, and then crossed into Austria in May. 

 Moving into Austria, the battalion was part of General Patton's southeastern spearhead, fighting in support of the 71st Infantry Division. This move into Austria is fascinating.

Many think of Patton's 3rd Army race across France and Germany as its, and his, dominant achievement, and that is arguably so. But, as you can see from the map above, Patton's 3rd Army also spearheaded a significant move to the southeast into Austria. The 761st was at the lead of this spearhead.

The red box on the map marks the area of Linz-Enns-Steyr. This is the general area where the 761st ended up. 

There is a great deal of "intrigue" involved in the Allied (mainly Patton's 3rd Army) movement into Austria, which we cannot cover here. American commanders in April 1945, General Patton of the 3rd Army perhaps the most vocal, were ready and in position to go into Berlin, far to the north of Austria. That was most certainly Patton's goal. But General Eisenhower, the Supreme Allied Commander, said "no." He decided to let the Soviets take Berlin instead, in part because Berlin was in the "Soviet sphere of influence" in Germany, in part because the battle for Berlin was going to be costly, and in part because he wanted to solidify Allied gains to the west, and to the south.

He decided to stop the US advance at the Elbe River, which originated in Czechoslovakia just north of the East-west Danube. The Elbe flowed  northward through Germany to the North Sea. The Americans were all around the Elbe, and the Enns-Danube just to the south, but they were not easy to find.

Each American unit wanted to be the first to find the Soviets. Dozens of American patrols were sent out searching for them. The 761st was among those initial units to meet up with the Soviets in the area of Steyr, Austria, just to the south of Linz.

The Soviets began their attack on Berlin on April 21 and captured the city on May 2.

We have not even touched on the many, many crucial battles in which the 761st fought. In reading the battalion's history, it clearly fought with enormous courage and sacrifice, as well as or better than most others.

 The battalion was deactivated in 1946 in Germany, but was reactivated at Fort Knox, Kentucky in November 1947. It was deactivated for good in March 1955.

The battalion was awarded the Presidential Unit Citation on January 24, 1978, long overdue, many rightly argue, wrongly overdue. Rather than arguing that point, it's better to highlight a few sections of the citation, where the prose is particularly inspiring and reflective of the accomplishments of the soldiers of the 761st Tank Battalion:

“The 761st Tank Battalion distinguished itself by extraordinary gallantry, courage, professionalism and high esprit de corps displayed in the accomplishment of unusually difficult and hazardous operations in the European Theater of Operations from 31 October 1944 to 6 May 1945. During 183 days in combat, elements of the 761st - the first United States Army tank battalion committed to battle comprised of black soldiers - were responsible for inflicting thousands of enemy casualties and for capturing, destroying, or aiding in the liberation of more than 30 major towns, 4 airfields, 3 ammunition supply dumps, 461 wheeled vehicles, 34 tanks, 113 large guns, 1 radio station, and numerous individual and crew-served weapons. This was accomplished while enduring an overall casualty rate approaching 50 percent, the loss of 71 tanks, and in spite of extremely adverse weather conditions, very difficult terrain not suited to armor operations, heavily fortified enemy positions and units, and extreme shortages of replacement personnel and equipment. The accomplishments are outstanding examples of the indomitable spirit and heroism displayed by the tank crews of the 761st … The men of the 761st Tank Battalion, while serving … in 183 continuous days in battle, fought major engagements in six European countries, participated in four major allied campaigns and on 6 May 1945, as the easternmost American soldiers in Austria, ended their combat missions by joining with the First Ukrainian Army (Russian) at the Enns River, Steyr, Austria.” 

In 1997, Staff Sergeant Ruben Rivers received the Congressional Medal of Honor (posthumously) for his heroism with Company A during the period November 14-19, 1944 in the area of Guebling, France. He had originally received the silver star and a purple heart (both posthumously) for his actions on those days.

Readers might be interested to know the world-famed baseball star, Jackie Robinson, was an officer in the 716th. He was drafted in 1942. Robinson was once heard to say, “A life is not important, except in the impact it has on other lives.”

Well, as we all know, he had a major impact on baseball, not only as a terrific and talented player, but because he broke the segregation barrier and did it with a flare. He was the first African-American to play in the majors, became Rookie of the Year with the Brooklyn Dodgers, and two years later became MVP. He finished with a lifetime batting average of .311 and was voted into the Hall of Fame in his first year of eligibility.

That all happened after Robinson served in the Army, with the 761st. Robinson did his basic training at Fort Riley, Kansas, with none other than Joe Louis, by then a world reknown boxer. Robinson had a degree from UCLA, but could not get into Officer Candidate School (OCS), until Louis intervened and pulled the right strings. In 1943, he graduated a second lieutenant.

A court martial stopped Robinson from going to Europe with the 761st. While riding a bus from Camp Hood, Texas, he refused the bus-driver's instruction to sit in the back of the bus. Court martial charges were drawn up but his white commanding officer, Major Paul Levern Bates (eventually promoted to colonel), refused to consent to the charges. Superior officers then moved Robinson to the 758th Tank Battalion, where the commander did consent to the charges. The 761st in the mean time departed for Europe during his trial. Actually, the charges had to do with his interaction with the military police following the bus incident. He was acquitted, and honorably discharged in 1944. He took the field for the Brooklyn Dodgers in 1947.

And meet Sergeant Warren G.H. Crecy, who later won a battlefield commission to lieutenant. You might not know it looking at this photo of him, but his comrades knew him as "the baddest man in the 761st."

On November 10, 1944, he fought through enemy positions, saw his tank destroyed, grabbed another vehicle with a .30-caliber machine gun, and eliminated the enemy position that destroyed his tank. He then took down enemy foreign observers who were directing artillery against American infantry units. The next day, his tank got stuck in the mud, he dismounted and, under fierce fire, got his tank unstuck and on the move. His tank then became immobilized, he saw German soldiers counterattacking US infantry, and provided cover fire with his .50 caliber until the American foot soldiers could withdraw. He then wiped out several machine-gun nests and an anti-tank position with his machine gun. A correspondent watching all this commented:

“To look at Warren G.H. Crecy, you'd never think that here was a 'killer,' who had slain more of the enemy than any man in the 761st. He extracted a toll of lives from the enemy that would have formed the composition of 3 or 4 companies, with his machine guns alone. And yet, he is such a quiet, easy-going, meek-looking fellow, that you'd think that the fuzz which a youngster tries to cultivate for a mustache would never grow on his baby-skinned chin. And that he'd never use a word stronger than 'damn.' But here was a youth who went so primitively savage on the battle field that his only thought was to 'kill, kill, kill,' and he poured his rain of death pellets into German bodies with so much reckless abandon and joy that he was the nemesis of all the foes of the 761st. And other men craved to ride with Crecy and share the reckless thrill of killing the hated enemy that had killed their comrades. And he is now living on borrowed time. By all human equations Warren G.H. Crecy should have been dead long ago, and should have had the Congressional Medal of Honor, at least!"

We'll let you read the stories of the countless other demonstrations of extraordinary heroism, including that of Staff Sergeant Ruben Rivers, who ultimately received the nation's highest military honor.

Joseph E. Wilson, Jr. did an extensive article on the 761st for World War II Magazine in January 1998. Here is Joseph Wilson's summary of this battalion's work in WWII.

"Through six months of battle, without relief, the 761st Tank Battalion served as a separate battalion with the 26th, 71st, 79th, 87th, 95th and 103rd Infantry divisions and the 17th Airborne Division. Assigned at various times to the Third, Seventh and Ninth armies, the Black Panthers fought major engagements in six European countries and participated in four major Allied campaigns. During that time, the unit inflicted 130,000 casualties on the German army and captured, destroyed or aided in the liberation of more than 30 towns, several concentration camps, four airfields, three ammunition supply dumps, 461 wheeled vehicles, 34 tanks, 113 large guns, and thousands of individual and crew-served weapons. This was accomplished in spite of extremely adverse weather conditions, difficult terrain not suited to armor, heavily fortified enemy positions, extreme shortages of replacement personnel and equipment, an overall casualty rate approaching 50 percent and the loss of 71 tanks."

Tuesday, June 11, 2019

Viet Vets talk - Listen and hear them (Part 1)

I belonged to a social media group that enables Vietnam veterans to “swap their experiences” and voice their memories. No politics allowed, nor profanity, nor disrespect. Most of the men and women who share their experiences with this group fought on the ground. I have found their comments to be stimulating, filled with passion, tears, pride and great sensitivity. I thought I should try to highlight the themes these men and women present.

I have collected many of their memories. I will convey some of them in this Part 1, and follow up later with additional sections.  I hope those who did not serve in Vietnam read these memories to better understand what these men and women have one through, then and now.

Daily greetings

“Do not regret growing older. It’s a privilege denied to many. Together we served. Just an old soldier looking to be in the company of other old soldiers.”

“Good night old friend. I fought for you once and I’d do it again. Love you brothers and sisters.”

“Today's morning message is for all of my Vietnam Veterans. Many blessings are being sent to you for a peaceful Monday. As one of those who has been protected by you, I will never know what you have experienced. What I do know is that I am forever grateful for each and every one of you. It's truly an honor and privilege for me to be able to thank you for serving our country. You will always have a special place in my heart. Welcome Home, my Veterans, Welcome Home! With much love and respect.”


 “Let my flag wave proudly to the people that I serve.” 

“Viet-Freakin Nam. Freedom runs deep for those who fight for it.”

“This ground is sacred. Please show these men the respect, dignity and honor which they have earned by giving the ultimate sacrifice when their country called.”  

“On the 8th day God created the Paratrooper, and Hell cried, ‘Airborne.’”

“We, the willing led by the unwilling are doing the impossible for the ungrateful. We have done so much with so little for so long we are now qualified to do anything with nothing, and get it done fast.”

“I was that which others did not want to be. I went where others feared to go, and did what others failed to do. I asked nothing from those who gave nothing and reluctantly accepted the thought of eternal loneliness —- should I fail. I have seen the Face of terror; felt the stinging cold of fear; and enjoyed the sweet taste of a moment’s love. I have cried, pained, and hoped ——but most of all, I have lived times others would say were best forgotten. At least someday I will be able to say that I was proud of what I was —- a Soldier.” 

“Amen. We did our duty with as much honor, dignity and courage as we could muster. The suits, well they have our blood on their hands.”

"He was an Air Force fighter pilot, F-4's, made it a career and retired as a light colonel. We chatted a while and he told me that even though he had been stationed at Langley, had been in DC hundreds of times, and was now standing just up the hill, he had never been to the Wall. Just can't go, he said. I was amazed but as we talked I began to realize why he didn't want to go. He had told me about the bravery of combat troops on the ground, calling in air support right on top of their positions, and how close his ordnance would be to them. I felt that he held himself personally responsible for names on that wall. I said, Colonel, you got to go. For yourself, for them."

“In 1986 I decided to march at Bristol, Rhode Island... I quickly found the Vietnam vets' contingent. We sat or stood about, swapping war stories and jokes, and soon it was time to form up. We had a cadence caller, a grizzled and bearded little Special Forces master sergeant with a Silver Star, Bronze Star, Purple Heart with clusters, and more chest candy than a North Korean general. And before you knew what was what, an A-10 zoomed over, almost at treetop level, and that was the signal to step off.

"Flags, flags, flags. Flying bright and brave from porches. Soaring proud from front-yard poles. Waving back and forth in spectators' hands. Music, music all around us. And I noticed one heartening thing.

“The people were sitting, enjoying things. But as they heard the ordered tramp of boots, heard our cadence caller singing it out, saw our group approaching - they came to their feet and screamed! ‘Welcome home!’ ‘Thanks, guys!’ ‘America!’ ‘USA! USA!’

“On the porch steps of one old Victorian home, two tall, thin old men in suits and ties, garrison caps on their heads and medals on their chests, stood at rigid attention holding salutes. ‘Eyes - Left!’ shouted our cadence caller as he snapped one back at them. History coming alive before us. And, yes. We were part of that history, we realized afresh.

“All the sirens in the fire station and in their engines sounded off and the cheers were deafening as we gave the stand an ‘eyes right’ and showed Bristol and the world what pride and service were all about! A bell began to ring in a nearby steeple. Pandemonium. Joy. America.”

The pain

“Not everyone who lost his life in Vietnam died there. Not everyone who came home from Vietnam ever left there.”

“As an USAF guy, I did not see or endure what you guys did on the ground. What maddens me the most as I grow older is how the suits messed that war up beyond repair, and how the people back home turned against our forces. Those things I will take to my grave.”

“We loved our country when our country didn’t love us.” 

“It was like we came home to a foreign land. I was very confused about it all at first, then the rage hit.” Another, “Some of the past was very hurtful and still lingers ... Yeah, not so much that I was mistreated, but the lack of respect, and indifference by everyone. No acknowledgement, nor sense of accomplishment from anyone."

 “It took me till the 15th of October this year (2014) to go (to the Vietnam Wall). I was Army 68/69 in Nam. Cried my eyes out. Knew a lot of friends on the Wall.”
“Sometimes I feel guilty because I made it and some of my men died … I salute you all my brothers, dead and alive.” … “Yeah buddy, the survivor guilt thing hits me once in while,, though I was just a SP/4 … still, some of my pals, squad members didn't make it, my brothers …”

 “Vietnam vets gave up more than liberty and life, family or loved ones. We gave up the person we had grown to be, we gave up our future, our hopes and all of our dreams, and we gave up the ones who loved us the most. Young fathers died in battles fought long ago. They never saw their children or held them in their arms. They never wiped away a tear or saw their first smile. Children's pictures were like treasures, cradles in their hands. They were protected like gold, diamonds or silver wrapped in the steel of an ammo can. Their voice was something so many vets would never hear, but their hearts beat as one, the blood of a vet passing from father to son.”

“Amen to that. Hope you libtards (liberal retards) love your freedom at the cost of True Americans.”

“Ain’t the size of the man in the fight, it’s the size of the fight in the man.”

“When I was in Vietnam I was numbuh ten thousand. When I returned back to the world I was a zero. Should-a stayed in Nam!”

Cadence calls

 “If I die bury me face down in the grass so the whole damn world can kiss my ass.”

“GI bread and GI gravy. GI wish I joined the Navy."

 “The prettiest girl that I ever saw, was sipping Bourbon tru a straw, I picked her up I layed her down, her pretty hair right on the ground. Give me you left right left your left.”

“Ain't no need in lookin' down, ain't no discharge on the ground. Ain't no need in going home, Jody's got your girl and gone. Ain't no need in lookin' back, Jody's got your Cadillac. Ain't no need in lookin' blue, Jody's got your sister to.”

“If I die in a combat zone box me up and ship me home. Pin my medals upon my chest and tell my mama I’ve done my best.”

“You had a good home but you left. ‘You're Right’ Your mama was there when you left. ‘You're right’ Your daddy was there when you left. ‘You're right’ Your girl was there when you left. ‘You're Right’ Jody was there when you left. ‘You're right’ Your sister was there when you left. ‘You're right’”     

A final thought


Tuesday, June 4, 2019

The loss of Oyster One Alpha - Major Bob Lodge, USAF

Major Bob Lodge, USAF, Lynbrook, New York, a 1964 graduate of the US Air Force Academy , and member of the 555th “Triple Nickel” Fighter Squadron, 432nd Tactical Reconnaissance Wing , Udorn Royal Thai Air Force Base, spent two tours in the Indochina War, flew 186 combat missions in fighters, and shot down three enemy MiGs. 

On May 10, 1972, Lodge, flying an F-4 Phantom II jet fighter, callsign Oyster One, was shot down over North Vietnam by North Vietnamese (NVN) Air Force (NVNAF) MiG-19s. Lodge was killed. His backseater and Weapons Systems Officer (WSO), Capt. Roger Locher bailed out and was rescued some 23 days later west of Hanoi in what was among the most harrowing rescue missions of the war.

By way of brief background, the Paris Peace Negotiations, underway in one form or another, began in 1968. By February 1970 they were deadlocked. On May 14, 1971, the NVN Politburo directed that a major offensive against the RVN occur in 1972. It was to be an all out attack, one that would employ virtually the entire North Vietnamese Army (NVA). The plan was ready in June 1971.  

The NVA invaded the RVN on March 30, 1972 with about 30,000 troops, tanks, artillery, and surface-to-air missiles. By April 1972 the NVN had committed 12 of its 13 major regular combat divisions.

As a result, President Nixon directed the JCS to develop an air attack plan against NVN. It came to be known as "Linebacker I."

Linebacker I had two major objectives. First, stop the NVN offensive. Second, take the war to the enemy’s heartland, to wit, Hanoi and Haiphong.

On May 10, 1972, 

Bob Lodge and Roger Locher led Oyster flight into the NVN.

The History Channel, in its “Dogfights Season 2: The Bloodiest Day” video, presents you a blow by blow animation of the massive air fights that occurred on this say. I commend it to you. Its video starts like this:

“In the air war over Vietnam, one day stands out among all the rest: May 10, 1972. The full fury of American air power was unleashed on North Vietnam. More North Vietnamese MiGs are shot down on this day than on any other day of the war.”

The day began at 0730 hours, May 10, 1972, when 30 USN fighters from the USS Constellation launched the first assault against North Vietnam. The intent was to cripple the communist invasion of the South that had begun on March 30, 1972. 

The Navy targeted petroleum storage tanks in the port of Haiphong, which the Navy had also mined.

Navy F-4 Phantoms from VF-92 flew escort. US surveillance resources issued Mig warnings. Several F-4s peeled away from escort and successfully took on the MiGs. Once the attacking force finished its work over Haiphong, it returned to the Constellation.

The day’s attacks were coordinated. USAF fighters congregated over Laos and refueled, employing six KC-135 tankers. The strike package was composed of 32 F-4 Phantoms, while 28 more flew escort, with about 60 more aircraft flying support missions such as jamming and intelligence collection.

This is when Oyster flight of four Phantoms from Udorn RTAFB flew into North Vietnam toward Hanoi from the southwest at low altitude to avoid radar. Its job was to patrol the airspace ahead of the strike package, working to make sure no MiGs posed a threat. Two other F-4s, Balter Flight, flew behind them and above them. 

The idea was to allow enemy radar to spot Balter Flight with a view toward luring enemy fighters. The plan then was for Oyster Flight, staying at low altitude to avoid detection, to engage them by surprise.

Bob Lodge (Oyster One Alpha) with Roger Locher (Oyster One Bravo) were the flight lead. John Markle with Stephen Eaves flew Oyster 2. Steve Ritchie flew Oyster 3 with Chuck Debellvue.

Four MiG-21s approached from west of Hanoi at 15,000 ft. Oyster Flight moved to engage. Lodge took the first two shots with his missiles and destroyed one MiG-21. A furious air battle ensued. If you studied this battle you would learn how many air-to-air missiles failed to detonate, or ran out of fuel and burned out, or failed to track and flew off aimlessly. Nonetheless, the pilots fought hard and shot down three out of four MiGs, Lodge, Markle and Ritchie getting one MiG-21 each.

Lodge then found another MiG and engaged him. He got too close to use his missiles. Markle flew behind Lodge to protect his rear. Suddenly two MiG-19s popped into the fight in an ambush and flew in between Markle and Lodge. The MiG-19s had cannons and began firing at Lodge. Lodge’s right engine was hit, the Phantom caught fire and started spinning out of control in a flat spin.

Lodge's F-4 rolled on its back, the fire spread, Locher punched out successfully and escaped and evaded for some 23 days. But Lodge stayed with his aircraft and was killed. For some time thereafter, the feeling was Lodge could not escape and had no choice but to go down with his ship.

The rest of the attack and escort force proceeded to their targets. One of the targets was the Paul Doumer bridge east of Hanoi. Countless previous attacks had gone after this bridge, all failing to bring it down. However this attack force was equipped with electro-optic or television guided bombs, called Walleyes, and laser guided munitions called Paveways. Multiple bombs hit their target, and the Doumer Bridge was at long last disabled.

The Navy brought on the third phase of attacks for the day. 

The strike group began its attacks against the Hailing railyards. What would happen next, and the Navy F-4 pilots had not expected this, was the most intense MiG air-to-air combat of the war.

By the end of the day, the Americans had destroyed 11 MiGs, the most ever shot down in a single day. The Navy scored eight of the 11, the USAF three. The Navy lost two aircraft, all four crew rescued. The Air Force lost one, one pilot killed (Lodge), one crew (Locher) ejected and was ultimately rescued.

That was the air battle on May 10, 1972, the “Bloodiest Day” for enemy MiGs.

I need to return to the question of why Major Lodge did not bail out.

Colonel Marshall Michel, USAF, in his book, Air Combat over North Vietnam 1965-1972, told of a program called "Combat Tree." Colonel Michel wrote that Oyster one carried  equipment known as the QRC-248 enemy IFF transponder interrogator. Michel wrote:

“(Combat) Tree F-4s could see and identify the MiGs on their own radar screens even at low altitude; now flights of F-4s with Trees could be sent on MIGCAP (MiG Combat Air Patrol) into North Vietnam, arriving before the strikers and setting up patrols between the MiG airfields and the target to cover the strike and chaff flights as they entered North Vietnam...

“A MIGCAP ideally obtained two Tree F-4Ds in the number 1 and 3 positions and two cannon armed F-4Es as number 2 and number 4; unless absolute unavoidable, there was always one Tree aircraft in the flight.”

Combat Tree at the time was a highly classified piece of equipment. As of early 2017, the program and equipment details remained classified.

Michel specifically addressed Oyster 1, Major Lodge. He wrote:

“The loss of Oyster 1 had been especially disturbing; he (Lodge) had been the wing weapons officer at Udorn and the most knowledgeable pilot in the wing about the Combat Tree system. He had scored his third kill just before he was shot down, and he appeared to be well on his way to being the first Air Force ace. After the back seater (Roger Locker) was picked up and explained how the front seater (Lodge) had deliberately ridden the aircraft down rather than take the chance on being captured and interrogated by the North Vietnamese, no one was surprised ---‘He was that kind of guy’ was the common opinion.”

Ritchie would later say Lodge and Locher were considered by their colleagues to be the best fighter crew in Southeast Asia. Lodge and Locher were credited with three MiG kills, one MiG-21 occurring on May 8, 1972, just two days before their aircraft was shot down, the first on February 2, 1972, also a MiG-21.

On September 30, 1977, Major Lodge’s remains were returned to US control.